Will Facebook private Daten weitergeben?

Ergänzt, 18.38

Die Bemerkungen zu sozialen Netzwerken, die auf diesem Blog

> Web 2.0 und soziale Netzwerke

vorgestellt und erläutert wurden, bündelt die Kritik an sozialen Netzwerken, mit denen Facebook, StudiVZ, XING u.a. uns helfen möchten, soziale Beziehungen zu gestalten.

Ein Vortrag auf dem Barcamp in Mannheim 2007:

> Stadtplanung und soziale Netzwerke im Web 2.0 (I)
> Stadtplanung und soziale Netzwerke im Web 2.0 (II)
> Stadtplanung und soziale Netzwerke im Web 2.0 (III)
> Stadtplanung und soziale Netzwerke im Web 2.0 (IV)

Mit der Anmeldung an ein solches Netzwerk unterwirft man sich den Datenschutzrichtlinien, die von diesen Unternehmen, wie jüngst dies Faceboook zu erkennen gegeben hat, jederzeit geändert werden können. Soziale Netzwerke geben Regeln vor, wie man andere Mitglieder kennenlernt, das hat mit dem richtigen sozialen Leben gar nichts zu tun. X ist jetzt mit y verbandelt, befreundet, wie auch immer, wird je nach Einstellung allen (Freunden) mitgeteilt. Hat man eigentlich Lust, sich stundenlang mit der Einstellung seiner elektronischen Existenz zu beschäftigen?

Profile werden automatisch wie bei der Rasterfahndung abgeglichen, neue Kontakte werden vorgeschlagen. Man möge sich vorstellen, wie es wäre, wenn man im Leben nur Gleichgesinnte kennenlernen würde? Und man kann gucken, wer mit wem befreundet ist. Was ist das für ein Begriff von Freundschaft? Natürlich ist der Schatz von privaten Informationen eine Goldmine für die Werbung, eine Riesenversuchung für den Betreiber solcher Seiten, damit Unfug zu Lasten der Nutzer anzustellen.

Jetzt beklagt sich zu Recht die Ministerin für Verbraucherschutz Ilse Aigner über das Ansinnen von Facebook, persönliche Daten der Nutzer von Facebook weiterzugeben:

> Aigner zieht in den Kampf gegen Facebook SPIEGEL online, 5.4.2010

Mag es auch einen vielleicht versteckten Knopf geben, der angeklickt werden kann, um die Weitergabe der Daten zu verhindern; was zählt ist der Versuch von Facebook die Daten seiner Nutzer zu ihrem Nachteil zur Mehrung des eigenen Gewinns auszunutzen.

Man kann natürlich der Ansicht sein, > Es gibt keine private Daten in Social Networks. Aber so einfach kann man oder gar Facebook es sich allerdings nicht machen. Auch im Account von Nutzern soziale Netzwerke, kann es Daten geben, die diese nicht als Daten verstehen, mit denen der Netzwerkbetreiber machen kann, was er will. Das erinnert ja auch an die bekannten Diskussion um Wikipedia. Wer da etwas hineinschreibt, muss es wohl oder übel der Allgemeinheit übereignen, deren Wächter sich sogleich an das Korrigieren und Infragestellen des Textes machen. Wird es in sozialen Netzwerken auch einmal dazu kommen? Wie auch immer, mit seinen Pläne maßt Facebook sich eine Verfügungsgewalt über die Daten seiner Nutzer an, die nicht unbedingt in derem Interesse sein müssen. Diese Diskussion erinnert auch an die Debatte um das > Urheberrecht. Ein Autor sondern jeder von uns, der nicht mehr Herr im Sinne des Urheberrechts des Publikationsortes seiner Texte ist, verliert ein Stück seiner Freiheit. – Möchten wir, dass die Daten unserer Facebook-Accounts mit anderen Daten, die wir gar nicht kennen, verglichen oder abgeglichen werden?

Mehr zu diesem Thema:
> Privatsphäre wird weiter eingeschränkt TAZ 29.3.2010

Stadtplanung und soziale Netzwerke im Web 2.0 (IV)

english french german 

The following four articles summarize the talk given last Saturday at the > Barcamp in Mannheim, where Robert Basic and I asked What is the social nature of social networks? . This presentation was intended to spark discussion; while the debate was highly contentious, it also highlighted the value of social networks.

> Urban Planning and Social Networks in Web 2.0 (I)
> Urban Planning and Social Networks in Web 2.0 (II)
> Urban Planning and Social Networks in Web 2.0 (III)
> Urban Planning and Social Networks in Web 2.0 (IV)

As per the blog, the latest post (i.e., (IV)) appears first here. It is therefore best to scroll down the page or click here to start with > Urban Planning and Social Networks on Web 2.0 (I).

In social networks such as > Facebook, there is no hierarchy, unless the number of contacts indicates something about social status. It primarily reflects the amount of time the well-known person has already spent on this platform. No one walks across a public square and greets everyone with a handshake, because they know everyone passing by. Unfortunately, the person we know well becomes an object for which we vote.

Sennett raises the question—and explicitly rejects it—that a society cannot build a community based on intimate acquaintances. ((The Decline and End of Public Life: The Tyranny of Intimacy, in English The Fall of Public Man, Frankfurt am Main, 1983, p. 333) Applied to social media, this means that no network can be created based on knowledge of profiles, since lasting reciprocity is not involved. What is discussed here on a small scale can be applied to urban design and urban planning. A prime example will soon emerge in Stuttgart. The removal of the railroad tracks, the 90-degree rotation of the train station, and the construction of a new neighborhood on the site of the numerous railroad tracks that currently lead to a terminal station are collectively known as Stuttgart 21. Commercial buildings, residential units, and the 21st-century library are set to rise from the former track area.

A few images from the early days, around 2003, of the development behind Stuttgart’s central station:


Can a neighborhood be created from scratch? Urban planners are convinced it can. It is hoped that this new neighborhood will have a ripple effect on the surrounding area, as the size of the site makes it a significant urban planning project—even if it is just one neighborhood. The mix of functions in this new neighborhood will be key to its success. What influences will come from outside? What functions will be brought together there? There is no doubt that the urban planners are aware of their responsibility, for they know that it is not enough simply to build houses; rather, they are building—in the truest sense of the word—the social fabric of the new neighborhood. Its prospects are set in stone and may only have proven viable after the inauguration, to truly lay the foundation for an urban community.

It is not the architecture of the houses, but the functions of the various buildings that determine how society can be built. The 21st-century library, located at the heart of the new neighborhood, will reportedly be surrounded by a moat. It is possible that it will be accessible only through a gate on one side, facing downtown. Just as the arrangement of functions will determine the well-being and comfort of work in this new neighborhood—and, to a lesser extent, in the new library—these sociological perspectives and insights into urban planning must also be applied to the rules and functions of social networks, which constitute the conditions for society’s success.

Urban planning and social networks differ very little from one another. And these conditions are shaped by those who receive money for making the budget available. Paying for one’s own advertising on a regular basis—like a hairdresser’s ad or the monthly gas bill—is still something that takes some getting used to. For some, this amount is even a kind of tax on livelihood.

To the first article in the series > Urban Planning and Social Networks in Web 2.0

Supplement:
Kai Biermann,> Networking Can Hurt, DIE ZEIT, Oct. 21, 2008

Stadtplanung und soziale Netzwerke im Web 2.0 (II)

english french german 

There is still a need for a sociology of the Internet, and my remarks during the session with Robert Basic at the > Barcamp in Mannheim were an attempt to approach the topic of social networks from a different angle.

The thesis:
Exchanges, “teleports,” friend requests, contacts, and the sharing of little hearts—all of this results in documented relationships that reflect a personal culture having nothing to do with the public sphere or public social relationships, because electronic contact is ephemeral, allows one to withdraw at any time, and requires only a minimal degree of responsibility for the new relationship. – Why is a request for contact made? Do we want to expand our own list of acquaintances, or do we want to become better known ourselves? How many contacts can we handle? It’s very easy not to respond to a contact request; the other person isn’t notified. In this kind of game, we allow a third party to regulate our relationship—which isn’t even a relationship yet. This is just one small aspect of an entire network in which not only my contact, but also the network operator and even the network community play a role in shaping how my relationships are organized. When you consider the number of different rules governing forums, the ability to personally initiate contact seems strangely limited.

Do I perceive the other person solely on the basis of the qualities they display? Isn’t a person interesting precisely because they react in a wonderfully individual, incomparable, and unique way in a given situation—something their profile will never capture? People post their profiles online and become strangely anonymous. No social media profile allows for the weighting of personal interests within a profile. Nor is this necessary; after all, the profile takes the same form for everyone—every visitor wants to be able to navigate each page in the same way, in accordance with usability principles. The result is a standardization whose consequences remain unclear.

WilhelmsplatzIt may be possible to address this problem through architecture or urban planning. Let us consider, in turn, two squares that are intended to serve as spaces for public life. Wilhelmsplatz (I) in Stuttgart-Bad-Cannstatt (> A Site Visit) is the first example. Here, the creation of a public space where people can meet has been a complete failure. It is clear that a multitude of regulations of all kinds confine people’s movements to a restricted area, while other road users have been given their own traffic lanes.

WilhelmsplatzWilhelmsplatz
WilhelmsplatzWilhelmsplatz

Pedestrians are only tolerated on this square if they are willing to cross it quickly through the pedestrian gates. It is not a place where one can linger. As the center of a neighborhood, it has lost its function.

WilhelmsplatzWilhelmsplatz

Social media platforms like Facebook and others function in the same way on the Internet. Despite an ever-increasing number of features that offer a multitude of ways to present oneself, the framework for making contact is largely dictated by the designers of these networks—just like in a public square where people must move along predefined paths. What comes to mind when you think of this square? How can passersby reclaim this urban space?

Good question, especially on a weekend like this one, when Ulm residents are visiting the Weishaupt Museum at > Ulm’s Neuer Mitte, > Three new buildings, has been inaugurated.

Hans-and-Sophie-Scholl-Platz

Photo (c) City of Ulm. Courtesy of the City of Ulm.

The new museum is located directly on Hans-and-Sophie-Scholl Square, with which the residents of Ulm have finally and very impressively healed the city’s wartime wounds—wounds that the Neue Straße, between the cathedral and the old town, had until recently still served as a reminder of.

In addition to the obvious advantages offered by social media, their functioning and structure are open to criticism.

The second example: > Place de l’Homme de Fer in Strasbourg

> Urban Planning and Social Networks in Web 2.0 (I)
> Urban Planning and Social Networks in Web 2.0 (II)
> Urban Planning and Social Networks in Web 2.0 (III)
> Urban Planning and Social Networks in Web 2.0 (IV)

Stadtplanung und soziale Netzwerke im Web 2.0 (I)

english french german 

In late October 2007, Robert Basic, then author of the blog www.basicthinking.de (which he later sold), asked me if we wanted to participate in the > Barcamp in Mannheim, which took place in early November 2007, as well as at the > Barcamp in Munich to lead a session together. In Munich, the focus was on “Blogging: Practice and Theory” (> my Barcamp highlight). But during the discussion I mentioned, I said that we wouldn’t be presenting on the same topic, but that we’d talk about social media, for example. “Okay,” said Robert, “but how social are they?” “Very well, that’s the topic.”

Summary: The following four contributions examine the importance, scope, or potential of social networks. We illustrate our reflections by looking at urban planning. Let’s take a look at Wilhelmsplatz in Stuttgart-Bad-Cannstatt. Here, all road users are assigned the space they can use. Wilhelmsplatz functions like a social network on the Internet, with its many features—for which you have to register online and even pay if you want to use all of them. Or let’s take a look at Place de l’Homme de Fer in Strasbourg. Here, the entire square is open to all users—only the trams are required to stay on their tracks for technical reasons—Homme de Fer Square is like real life, with no spaces imposed as on Wilhelmsplatz, but only restrictions like in real life, so that no one gets hurt.

Social media are internet platforms, such as > www.xing.com, > www.schuelervz.net/, > www.studivz.net, > www.facebook.com, or > www.myspace.com, to name just a few of the best-known examples of this type, which have emerged on the Internet under the umbrella term “Web 2.0,” the participatory web.

On Saturday, we held the session How Social Are Social Networks? in Mannheim. And since we were in a room where—despite the otherwise perfect hospitality of the University of Mannheim—the projector wouldn’t connect to my laptop, I’m now sharing the photos in the following three articles that I used to illustrate the connection between urban planning and social networks on Web 2.0.

Continued: > Urban Planning and Social Networks in Web 2.0 (II)
> Urban Planning and Social Networks in Web 2.0 (III)
> Urban Planning and Social Networks in Web 2.0 (IV)